The "Other" Courses
By mjaber on 3/22/13
Not all golf courses are created equal. If you ask an average non-golfing person about a golf course, they are going to tell you what they have seen on TV. Par (if they know what it is) is 70 or 72 for 18 holes. Since the golf season in the northern states is just about to start, I want to spend a little time on the other courses, and their benefits.
Also, keep your "new-to-golf" friend in mind. If you're a bogey golfer, or better, taking your buddy to your favorite challenging course is not the best way to get him hooked on the game. The pitch-and-putt may not be the best bet either. I would suggest the executive Par 3 as a starting point for anyone who is out of middle school and looking to get into golf. It is challenging enough to give them a taste, but easy enough that they won't have to spend a weeks pay on golf balls.
This was written by Mike Jaber, a reader/follower/fellow oober and the opinions are 100% his and do not reflect those of oobgolf in anyway. Enjoy! I'm sure he's ready for your feedback.
Have an idea for a guest column? Send it here!
Image via Flickr, danperry
[ comments ]
Thanks for the well written and interesting article. As a kid in Massachusetts, we mainly played short courses falling anywhere from a par 3 course to a short executive-style layout.
The USGA does not allow a normal course rating & slope for courses under 3,000 yards (or 1,500 for 9 holes). You are correct that many Executive courses have a rating even though they are not standard length. One of the sportier layouts I have played is Mountain Shadows (3,081 yards; Par 56; 57.3/95 rating).
Nice writing, Mike. Executive courses do not seem to be popular around my area. I have never played one - the only one I have seen is at Garden City in the Myrtle Beach area. Around my area we have one poor quality pitch and putt and three longer halfway decent par3 courses. I haven't played them in a long time. One afternoon I did an unlimited play at one of them and walked it 5 times trying to shoot par, best round was +2. The longest hole at about 185 uphill, greens were not too bad.
joe jones says:
Good subject Mike. When I lived in Las Vegas we had a 18 hole executive course (Eagle Crest @ Sun City Summerlin) That was very difficult even for single digit players.The green complexes were very hard due to the valley effect playing at elevation. You had to allow 3 to 4 times the break you would read and until you got used to them nobody scored well. Billy Casper designed the course and when he dedicated the course by playing with our pro's he was asked how he liked the way the course turned out he said he "Would like to shoot the dumb s.o.b that made those greens" That coming from one of the best putters of all time.
Though slope ratings will disagree, I find par 3's tougher than 4's or 5's. Playing shorter, tighter courses - especially with wind/water/bunkers - can really sharpen up my game. However, I find the older courses almost useless at times because they rarely have yardage markings, and if they do, they are terribly misleading. While in general I don't have a problem with unmarked courses, and find them refreshingly old fashioned (150 bush anywhere from 120 to 180), they can befuddle an otherwise useful practice session/tune-up.
There are many 9-hole and even some 18-hole executives in the Minneapolis area. Most are on the site of a regulation course, which is real convenient. I agree, a great way to switch it up.
Pitch n putt is the true miniature golf. I have always liked it. Real golf only scaled down. My gf and I play a few times a year and from these outings she's learned a lot about basic rules and etiquette as well as the art of grinding out a score. I think she's now ready to graduate to full courses. No better way to get started in golf IMO. Good stuff Mjab.
Excellent article. I can say that as I was learning I've been to every course. Cut my teeth on an executive par 3 with my grandfather. I don't know if it's still there but I'd love to go back some day and play it. Also spend st of my childhood on an executive 9 hole course. They used to have a great rate. 12 bucks and play all day. My mom used to drop me.off at the course at 6 am and come back for me at dinner time. Those were the days. Now that same course is $24 for 18 holes.
joe jones says:
My first experience with golf was on a par three at Grant Park in South Milwaukee, Wi. When I was 16. A family friend that was 17 and a high school star and a scratch golfer took this visiting kid from Brooklyn under his wing. On the opening 150 yard par three he handed me a seven iron and said "just hit the hell out of it".It went over the green, over the tree behind the green and never to be found afterward.Freddy said "Oh my God your strong". I was hooked for life. The only difference now is that to hit that distance I need a seven wood. Oh Well!!!!
Tim Horan says:
We have a short course at Wildwood. They tried to make it difficult to make a real challenge...they certainly did that! It was so difficult with the carries over water, sand and rough that the juniors and beginners would not use it. It cost the club thousands to maintain each year with little to no revenue. Even the societies give it a miss. The club have decided to let it go wild now and are considering building lodges on the land. So Sad!
[ post comment ]