USGA and R&A Tweak Video Evidence Rule
By Torleif Sorenson on 11/19/13
Earlier this morning, the USGA and the Royal & Ancient jointly announced a total of 87 changes to the Decisions on the Rules of Golf. Perhaps the most noteworthy update is Decision 18/4:
New Decision 18/4 will provide that, where enhanced technological evidence shows that a ball has left its position and come to rest in another location, the ball will not be deemed to have moved if that movement was not reasonably discernible to the naked eye at the time. The Decision ensures that a player is not penalized under Rule 18-2 in circumstances where the fact that the ball had changed location could not reasonably have been seen without the use of enhanced technology.That rule would have been nice for Tiger Woods to have at the BMW Championship outside Chicago, where Woods (and a sizeable segment of the viewing audience) did not see his ball move in the rough, but some viewers did, thanks to high-definition television cameras. Woods was penalized for the incident, which led to Brandel Chamblee's ill-conceived "cheater" comment that got him bounced from Golf Magazine.
In their statement, the USGA said that the Rules of Golf Committees will discuss other issues revolving around television and video evidence, including...
...the necessary degree of precision in marking, lifting and replacing a ball, the estimation of a reference point for taking relief, and the overall question of the appropriate penalty for returning an incorrect score card where the player was unaware that a penalty had been incurred. As is true of the rules in many other televised sports, adapting to developments in technology and video evidence is an important ongoing topic in making and applying the Rules of Golf.Interestingly, 24 Decisions have been officially withdrawn, three decisions (including 18/4 above) are new, 59 Decisions have been revised, and one was re-numbered, but otherwise unchanged.
Read an interesting golf article? Tip Your Editor!
Image via USGA
[ comments ]
Decision 18/4, nicknamed the "Tiger Woods Rule".
joe jones says:
Thank God some sanity has come to the world of golf. These rule changes should benefit All golfers.
Torleif Sorenson says:
Keep in mind that this does NOT eliminate the possibility of viewers calling in rules infractions.
Also interesting is that some at the USGA and R&A *insist* that the Tiger Woods BMW kerfuffle was not the main catalyst behind this change. Of course, people say things all the time for political reasons.
FWIW, I have watched that high-definition video five times, and I still cannot see where the ball moved.
It didnt move much, but right as he tried to move the twig it moved. Then Tiger went over and pulled a club and chipped out, did the ball move far enough to matter, nope.
So when my buddy is video taping me and I fart and we all laugh so hard my ball falls off the tee, do any of these rules matter?
[ post comment ]